Collagen Sticks Vs. Bully Sticks: Which is Best for Your Dog?

Collagen Sticks Vs. Bully Sticks: which is best for your dog?

Choosing the right chew for your dog can feel like a tough choice. Both bully sticks and collagen sticks are popular, all-natural options, but they have important differences in durability, health benefits, and how they’re made. 

This guide helps you understand the key contrasts so you can choose the best natural chew for your furry friend.

The Main Differences: Bully Sticks vs. Collagen Sticks

Both chews are great, but they serve slightly different needs. The best choice often depends on your dog’s chewing habits, age, and health goals.

Why choose a bully stick?

Bully sticks have been a go-to chew for decades for good reason. They are a single-ingredient chew made from bull pizzle, which makes them highly digestible and perfect for dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies to other proteins. 

Their simple, straightforward nature is what makes them so appealing to dog owners who want a no-fuss, all-natural treat.

Exceptional palatability

Dogs love the rich aroma and meaty flavor of bully sticks. If your pup is a picky eater, this is often an irresistible option. The natural scent ensures an engaging and satisfying chew session, making it easier to redirect destructive chewing habits to something healthier.

High in protein, low fat

Because bully sticks are essentially pure beef muscle, they are naturally high in protein and low in fat. This makes them a good option for active dogs that need muscle support and energy boosters between meals, without adding unnecessary calories.

Dental health benefits

The tough yet digestible texture of a bully stick helps naturally scrape away plaque and tartar buildup as your dog chews. Regular chewing sessions can improve oral hygiene, reduce the risk of gum disease, and keep your dog’s breath fresher. For more tips on oral care, read about periodontal disease in dogs.

Why choose a collagen stick?

Collagen sticks are a newer, innovative option that goes a step further by offering powerful functional benefits. They are made from a concentrated source of collagen, a vital protein that plays a huge role in your dog’s overall health.

Supports joint and bone health

Collagen is the primary protein found in cartilage, tendons, and bones. As dogs age, their natural collagen production slows down, which can lead to stiffness and mobility issues. By chewing on a collagen stick, your dog gets an extra boost of this essential protein, helping maintain flexibility, mobility, and stronger bones. For senior dogs, treats for dogs with arthritis are also a great supportive option.

Promotes healthy skin and a shiny coat

The peptides in collagen sticks help hydrate and nourish the skin from within. This can lead to fewer dry spots, less itching, and a shinier, healthier coat. If your dog struggles with dull fur or seasonal dryness, collagen chews can be a delicious and supportive solution.

Superior durability

Collagen sticks are denser than bully sticks, which means they hold up longer, especially for power chewers. Many owners find them to be more cost-effective over time since they last up to 20% longer than a bully stick of the same size.

Making the right choice for your dog

The "best" chew is the one that fits your dog's needs and preferences.

Choose a bully stick if...

• More variation for all sizes: jumbo, thin, thick, standard sizes;

• They are a picky eater and you want a highly palatable, classic chew;

• You want a high-protein, easily digestible treat with no added ingredients.

Choose a collagen stick if...

• Your dog is a heavy chewer and you need a longer-lasting option.

• They have joint issues, a dull coat, or could use extra bone support.

• You want a functional treat that offers extra health benefits beyond just chewing.

Want to explore even more safe and healthy alternatives? Discover our guide on rawhide alternatives for dogs.

Both bully sticks and collagen sticks for dogs are safe, natural, and healthy options. Your decision depends on whether your dog needs more protein and palatability or more joint and skin support.

At Natural Farm, all of our chews are made from 100% grass-fed, free-range beef with no chemicals, hormones, or preservatives. Whether you choose collagen sticks, bully sticks, or both, you can trust that your furry friend is enjoying a safe, high-quality, and nutritious treat.

Explore our full selection of collagen sticks for dogs and bully sticks for dogs to …to reward your pup with the best natural chews available.

 

---

 

FAQ - Collagen vs Bully Sticks for Dogs

 

Which lasts longer: collagen sticks or bully sticks?

Collagen sticks are denser and typically last up to 20% longer, making them a better option for aggressive chewers.

Are collagen sticks good for dogs with allergies?

Yes, collagen sticks are generally safe for dogs with food sensitivities, especially since they are a single-ingredient treat made from beef. However, always monitor your pet the first time they try a new chew.

Are bully sticks safe for puppies?

Bully sticks can be a good option for puppies once they have their permanent teeth. They are easy to digest and packed with protein, but supervision is essential to avoid choking hazards with small pieces. Learn more in why are dog chews good for puppies.

Which lasts longer: collagen sticks or bully sticks?

Collagen sticks are denser and typically last up to 20% longer, making them a better option for aggressive chewers.

Can collagen sticks replace bully sticks in my dog’s routine?

Not necessarily — each chew offers unique benefits. Many owners alternate between them to provide different flavors, textures, and health advantages.